Skip to main content

I Feel Defeated But Not Sure If I Should Quit

Audit Manager Series, #2

The Week She Stopped Recognising Herself

Wen Qi had four clients on her plate that quarter, each at a different stage of audit. Falcon Textiles' audit was ongoing. Northgate Pharma had a long list of outstanding review points not yet cleared. Brightfield Tyres was racing toward its reporting deadline. Summit Realty, her first-year client, was still getting used to working with her team. None of that, on its own, was unusual for a manager at her level.

Then, over about ten days, everything seemed to happen at once.

Her partner pulled her senior off Falcon Textiles to help cover another higher-risk audit, promising he'd sort out extra support by the end of the week. The week passed. Each time she asked, the answer was some version of still working on it.

With Falcon short-staffed, Wen Qi absorbed the gap herself, on top of Brightfield's looming deadline and Northgate's outstanding review points. She was in the office past midnight most days, and back at her desk before seven in the morning. She was exhausted.

Midweek, Summit Realty's CFO called, upset about the long list of schedules required from his accounting team. He told Wen Qi that his previous auditor never asked for so many schedules to be prepared. Wen Qi spent an hour explaining the reason, and promised to remove some schedules from the list. In that moment, she feared her own team would be upset with her for making that promise.

On Thursday, the day Brightfield's final draft financial statements were due, she was still halfway through her review. The finance director called her directly after he failed to reach the audit partner.

Finance Director: This is the third time I'm calling about the draft. We have a board meeting on Monday and I still don't have final numbers. I don't know what's going on over there, but this isn't acceptable.

Wen Qi: I understand, and I'm sorry. I'll have it to you by Monday at the latest.

Finance Director: Are you kidding me? We need the final draft today.

The call lasted four minutes and in that short span of four minutes, the only thing that Wen Qi did was either staying silent or apologising. She offered no excuses. This went on until the FD hung up in anger.

She sat at her desk for a long moment afterward, staring at nothing. Her hands were shaking slightly, and she hadn't eaten since last night. She wasn't sure if it was hunger or something else.

That evening, she sat at the bus stop and watched two of her buses come and go. She couldn't make herself stand up to board either one. She wasn't crying, not exactly. For those few minutes, it offered her some respite, only because no one could reach her there.

For the first time, she let herself think the sentence she'd been avoiding for weeks. I don't know if I can keep doing this.

What Could Possibly Be on Her Mind

By the time she reached the bus stop, Wen Qi wasn't thinking about Falcon's staffing gap or Summit Realty's schedules anymore. She was thinking that she had failed. That a good manager wouldn't have let Brightfield's review fall this far behind. That the finance director's anger was an accurate feedback on her own incompetence, and it's only a matter of time that everyone else would see it too. Whether any of that is actually true is a separate question because right now, it is exhaustion talking for Wen Qi, not the truth.

Wen Qi didn't create the gap on Falcon; her partner did, when he moved her senior elsewhere and then failed, twice, to deliver the replacement he'd promised. She didn't choose to run four demanding engagements short-handed; that was decided for her, without her agreement and without anyone adjusting her other deadlines to compensate. Brightfield's review fell behind because one person was carrying the workload of two, not because she is bad at her job. What she's calling failure is really the accumulated weight of decisions made above her, landing on the one person who kept showing up and said nothing.

What Matters Most Right Now

When several things go wrong at once like this, the instinct is to give up and quit. That's usually not the right call to make from here. But it's also worth being honest about what Wen Qi can actually manage tonight. She doesn't need a plan for her whole life, and in this state, she isn't capable of building one. The bar for tonight needs to be much lower than that.

The one thing genuinely within reach tonight is telling someone, even briefly. It doesn't have to be a full conversation. A short message to someone she trusts, I'm not okay, I need to talk soon, is enough for now. Saying it doesn't solve anything by itself. It just means she's no longer the only person who knows.

Wen Qi should also recognise that, in her current state, the support she needs may come from outside the office altogether. Shaking hands, sitting at a bus stop unable to move, and the thought I don't know if I can keep doing this, are not things to carry alone. Tonight, that might mean nothing more than getting home safely and eating something. In the days that follow, it may mean a doctor, an employee assistance programme if her firm has one, or a counsellor. None of that has to happen all at once, and none of it is a failure. There is no shame in asking for help.

When you're this exhausted, wanting the pain to stop can drive a person to think it's time to quit. Right now, Wen Qi's exhaustion is asking for relief, not offering real clarity about her career. That's exactly why the decision deserves to wait until the pressure has actually eased, because it's too unreliable to build a life decision on how she feels right now. This is why the larger question, whether to stay or eventually leave her firm, or the profession altogether, should wait.

One thing Wen Qi can do is get help from a clear-headed person to sort out what's genuinely urgent from what only feels urgent. The best person for this may be a mentor or a partner she trusts in the firm, if she has one. Wen Qi does not have the mind space to do this by herself in her condition. A second person, one step removed from the exhaustion, is often the only way to see clearly that Northgate's review points can wait a day while Brightfield's draft financial statements can't. Asking for that help isn't giving up. It's recognising how little any one person can reliably judge alone under this much pressure.

It's time to loop in her partner to share the burden. A senior confirmed for Falcon by Monday, or the partner reviewing Brightfield's draft financial statements directly, without waiting for her to finish her own review first, both matter. It doesn't have to happen tonight, but it must eventually be done. The staffing burden isn't hers to carry alone.

Looking Back, As an Audit Partner

When I look back on managers who eventually left the profession, very few resigned because of one difficult week. Most resigned after months of carrying more than what anyone around them realised, quietly hoping next week would be easier. By the time they finally said they were leaving, the decision had often been made long before anyone else knew.

That's why I don't worry most when a manager tells me they're struggling. I worry when they stop telling me altogether.

None of this fixes Falcon's staffing gap, or undoes Thursday's phone call. But those were never the real emergency. Neither is the decision to stay or go. The real emergency is that Wen Qi is running on empty, and protecting what's left of her mental health has to come first, before anything else.

If there is one thing this article tells you, it's this: if you are struggling, go talk to someone before you reach the breaking point.

If any part of Wen Qi's week feels familiar, you don't have to carry it alone either. Ask Your Mentor is exactly the place for that: somewhere to say the thing you haven't said out loud yet, and get a real answer back.


Once the pressure eases, and you're ready to actually think through what comes next
Some weeks make you wonder if you can keep doing this at all. When you're in a calmer place and the question is still there, there's a framework that can walk you through it properly: your finances, your options, your state of mind, all of it. Should I Quit? Get the guide here.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

My Senior Keeps Changing Her Mind

Junior Auditor Series: #01 When your audit senior's instructions keep changing mid-engagement The Message That Confused Her If your audit senior's instructions keep changing partway through a section, you're not alone. Read on to find out what it could actually mean. Mandy was in her second year of audit and had recently been assigned to audit a software company. Her senior told her to test 15 contracts for appropriate revenue recognition in line with IFRS 15. Mandy completed the testing, documented her results, and moved on to the next section. Three days later, her senior called her while she was at the client's office. Senior: Hi Mandy, we need you to test 40 contracts instead of the planned 15. Mandy: Sure, I can do that. Can I ask why the number went up so much? Senior: Robin found out from the client that some of the terms in certain contracts with customers were revised, so let's just play it safe and cover more ground this time. Remember to scrutin...

I Feel Caught Between My Manager and My Juniors

Audit Senior Series: #02 When you're the buffer between your manager's demands and your team's limits The Weekend Wei Ling Lost Do you often feel caught between your manager's demands and your team's limits? Read on to find out why audit seniors end up as the buffer, and what you can do about it. Marcus was midway through fieldwork on Denton Retail Group when Grace called on Thursday afternoon. Grace: The CFO needs finalised numbers ready for the board meeting this coming Monday morning instead of next Wednesday. Marcus: That's tough. Too short a notice. Can we get anyone else to help us cover this? Grace: I already tried. Nobody's free. Can the team work through the weekend? Marcus didn't answer straight away. He was thinking about Wei Ling, who'd asked for this exact weekend off three weeks ago. Her sister was flying in from Perth, first visit in two years. Marcus: Let me see what I can do. He sat with it after the call. Grace wasn...